English
2021.05.09 00:22

shanacrop filter issue

조회 수 7843 추천 수 0 댓글 2
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

크게 작게 위로 아래로 댓글로 가기 인쇄 첨부
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

크게 작게 위로 아래로 댓글로 가기 인쇄 첨부

Hello.

I believe cropping is not working. Here is parameters line I used:
-vf "crop=in_w-960:in_h,scale=1920:1080:flags=bicubic,shanacrop=DAR,setsar=1/1"

And the resulted video has cropped left & right bars with "crop" filter, but not cropped top & bottom with "shanacrop" during scaling down to 1080p and changed aspect ratio. So output is squashed. Please see attached screenshots.
Arguments other than "DAR" produce the same result.

 

input.png

output.png

P.S. I used to be able to crop 16:10 video to 16:9 with GUI settings in some previous version, but now cropping setting seems to do nothing. And I am also unable to find download for older versions on this site, which is a problem as well.

--
Thank you for your development.

 

Atachment
첨부 '2'
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Kakao
  • ?
    JKyle 2021.05.12 00:19

    You're doing crop ⇒ resize(scale) ⇒ crop. It's not a good work flow. Instead, do all the crops via [right click] > [Set segment/Crop] seeing the result in advance, and then do the resize.

    DAR means the display aspect ratio of the source. In resizing, Aspect: None or Padding (letterbox) is recommended. Don't do cropping there, 'cuz it will yield an unexpected result sometimes.

  • ?
    Leeroy 2021.05.19 23:49

    DAR means the display aspect ratio of the source.

    Is it? I was pretty sure that it is aspect ratio of ouput (at least in terms of ffmpeg), and it sure did act like that in previous ShanaEncoder versions. Setting output resolution of 1920x1080 and croping = DAR yilded for example 16:9 centered crop of 16:10 video without distortion.
    Even if I now set "shanacrop=16:9" or any other argument, the output is still identical. Does not seem right and very confusing.

    I was using this setting for simple reasons:

    a) it is located in main "Quick settings" menu, so seems like a logical way to do it.

    b) it requires no calculations in case you need centered picture output

    Thank you for pointing to "Set segment/Crop" menu, I was completely overlooking this submenu. It works well as a workaround.


List of Articles
번호 분류 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회 수 추천 수
공지 ShanaEncoder Translation 8 Rina 2021.04.28 73415 0
공지 This board is for users of the ShanaEncoder international version 7 Rina 2019.07.24 80262 1
176 English Request: Select Subtitle Files For multiple files at once " Built in subtitles for mkv files" 1 conencted09 2019.07.29 6733 1
175 English Preservation of the list of added video files. 1 Yar 2022.07.29 6856 0
174 English Would like to add task list export and import functionality. cjjdaq 2023.07.22 7037 0
173 English Black background 1 file tgif 2023.10.06 7363 0
172 English Recovering the file list after errors. 1 Yar 2020.07.17 7589 1
171 English When to add GPU 2PSS qsv 2pass 1 kedyao 2023.03.13 7591 0
170 English Can Shanaencoder use DebugFrameSever? ichbinkaiser 2019.05.18 7840 0
» English shanacrop filter issue 2 file Leeroy 2021.05.09 7843 0
168 English where is version 7 ???? 1 pontuuu 2023.12.30 7895 0
167 English import external audio bata 2020.02.20 8166 0
166 English Is the author of ShanaEncoder, LEE KIWON, the college entrance examination? av1 2019.06.02 8219 0
165 English 5.3.1.1 bug feedback 02——abnormal frame rate identification SUSU 2022.08.17 8252 0
164 English UTF-8 encoding value for subtitlle style 2 mrbean2 2019.01.18 8338 0
163 English Request: Set maximum decibel lec 2022.02.12 8430 0
162 English Dropping files into Shana v4.9.0.1 5 chessset5 2018.07.05 8472 0
161 English Encoding error 2 Deepspace 2021.07.30 8567 0
160 English Select Audio Stream for Multiple Files 1 conencted09 2019.02.21 8582 0
159 English Re-Encode to folder with same basename 2 MarkW 2018.10.29 8590 0
158 English Please take a look at the big guy and see what went wrong yangxuheng 2023.12.06 8693 0
157 English I'm encoding it, and the video's going 90 degrees. 1 ㅇㅇㅇㅇ 2021.03.14 8721 0
Board Pagination Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next
/ 10